I'm not sure why Todd recommends full tip valve removal, he didn't give a reason. I just removed the guts and snapped it back together (a hair dryer was helpful) with great results. Either solution should give the same end result.
Dennis,
It's logical that as you say "Either solution should give the same end result."
I'm not qualified to guess why Todd, or anybody else, would suggest one fix over another. However; based on personal experience
I'm inclined to go along with Todds advice and suggestions. Mostly because he has so much more hands on day to day experience with all things Guzzi than I.
Considering my ham fisted ability to break anything plastic I try to disassemble, The probability I'd have to replace the valve is quite high. So for me at least, it makes sense to pick up a few barbed fittings, and a variety of clamps at the local hardware store on the way home from work, and tackle the job just once.
The still whole valve is in the large container labeled "Guzzi Parts - Cali-1400" in my garage. If I ever sell the bike the next owner has the option to take the container.