I'd never accept something that is supposed to work, but doesn't work correctly, when I have paid my hard earned money for it. If you give me a car or bike for free with a check engine light I'd throw a scanner on it, see what it is, and then ignore it.
But not if I paid for it. If I pay for something it should be right. If someone sells something it should be correct.
MG has already admitted to the dealer, and to others in this thread, that the CEL and faulty 02Sensor is a known defect which requires them to redo the exhausts on newer models, but thus far hasn't resulted in a recall. Maybe because too many people are simply liviing with it
That's the no 1 issue. A secondary minor issue is it definitely affects resale. If I needed to sell the bike for whatever reason a CEL is going to significantly reduce the price someone would pay, which means it costs me money. I would get $1000 or more less than someone with the exact same bike if the other one doesn't have a CEL.
I just went through months of sorting out a 1996 Land Rover with a recurring CEL. Replaced plugs, wires, resealed the entire intake, replaced fuel injectors, the fuel filter, and the cap, all just to get the CEL from recurring so I could sell it in perfect condition - got a premium for it, too, since it may be the only Discovery 1 without a CEL flashing
I'm going to bow out of this conversation until I hear back from Piaggio - for some reason it has gotten antagonistic it seems, as though someone who expects something to work correctly is in the wrong. I mean for a rider support forum, there seems to be an idea from some that anyone who wants something to be fixed is wrong and should just live with it...some of the responses "oh quite intimidating" when I was simply pointing out I'm not a n00b to bikes and not simply overreacting about a stupid light are downright antagonistic - for what reason? To side with a company selling a faulty product over a buyer who is paying for it and wants it fixed?
I'll post updates for anyone else who also has this issue as I get them.